Am I alone in my long-term concerns?
Looking back, I'm thinking I would have wound up with a stronger, longer-lasting, wave-pounding-tolerant boat had my chines & shears been constructed with a greater number of thinner laminations. I constructed them with three pieces of 1/2" thick white oak, epoxied together. None of them enjoyed being bent to the bow shape, and every time I hit a big wave, I wonder if things are about to snap. I'm sure I'd have a stronger boat if I had built in layers making laminated shears / chines with something like twelve pieces of 1/8" thick white oak.
I also think that tite-bond III *might* have been a better choice of glue than epoxy for putting the chines / shears together. After all, if my chines & shears are immersed in water, that's called "sinking", and I have bigger problems to contend with!
For sure, my next boat will be made with a more "lamination" approach.
Or am I completely over-thinking this?
(I wish I had) laminated chines & shears with more-but-thinner strips
Moderators: Roberta, Bill Edmundson
- Bill Edmundson
- Posts: 12617
- Joined: Wed Nov 23, 2005 6:45 am
- Location: Birmingham, AL, USA
- Contact:
Re: (I wish I had) laminated chines & shears with more-but-thinner strips
Mark
Your over thinking this.
Bill
Your over thinking this.
Bill
Mini -Tug, KH Tahoe 19 & Bartender 24 - There can be no miracle recoveries without first screwing up.
Tahoe 19 Build
Tahoe 19 Build
Re: (I wish I had) laminated chines & shears with more-but-thinner strips
If the chines didn't break when you bent them, you're good to go.
Roberta
Roberta
Roberta "Queen of the Boat Builders"
Built Zip "Oliver IV", Super Spartan "Jimmy 70", and Torpedo "The Glen L".
Built SeaRey and RV-7A
Built Zip "Oliver IV", Super Spartan "Jimmy 70", and Torpedo "The Glen L".
Built SeaRey and RV-7A
Re: (I wish I had) laminated chines & shears with more-but-thinner strips
you need to get away from white oak,
it is grossly over-rated
it is grossly over-rated
Re: (I wish I had) laminated chines & shears with more-but-thinner strips
The hull plywood is what makes these boats strong more so than the framing. I crossed a wakeboat wake at 3/4 throttle last time I was out. The hull smacked and slammed HARD. I've done this many times. Inspecting the framing after a few outings there is zero change in any of the joints. You built your boat from tried and tested plans with proven methods. It's not going to fall apart.